Skip to main content

Should Books Be Adapted?


This is going to be a post you'll either whole-heartedly agree with or completely disagree with because that's how movie/TV adaptions of books work. You either love them or you wish they were never even imagined. We love the idea of them most of all. We all want to see the books we love on the screen, and, from what I've seen, we regret wishing for it in the end a lot of the time.
Movie and book adaptions are so tedious because some stories aren't made to be relayed through a screen. Books are so full of emotional subtext that's hidden in tiny details and in the voice and precise words spelled out on the page. There's so much more to a book than what you can portray on a running film of actual video even with voice overs. There are deep internal ramblings that make characters who they are that are hard to put on a screen because there are only so many tools to get internal during a movie.
Also, there are books that play out like movies in your head or make you feel like you're living in the world. Books hold power for different reasons, some of which lend better to movies than others. But no book is created to eventually become a movie, or it shouldn't be. If it was meant to be a movie, it would come out as a screenplay.
And, yet, adaptions are one of the biggest segments of movies that exist. Whether a book lends itself to adaption or not, if it sells well, it will probably be a movie. It's usually a rushed movie that's made to capitalize on the audience that has fallen in love with the book. They know that we'll all show up at the theater to watch it because we're all in book hangover world, and we just want more of that content we fell for. We want another chance to revisit the characters and places and emotions in a new way. Some of these adaptions are well thought through, involve the author, and are meticulously crafted. I'm glad that some of them exist, but so many of them are rushed, awkwardly spliced, and divorced from some of the subtext that makes the books soar. Book adaptions are an extremely delicate, and they're so rarely treated with that sense of care.
But here's the thing. No matter how much detail and movie magic you throw at a project, you can never touch book magic. The thing about a book is that it's intensely personal in the sense that you're forced to bring yourself, your emotions, and your life experience to fill it out. All you're given to work with is a packet of dead trees with black ink and 26 letters, and, somehow, we all have a collective experience with these created people and worlds. Yet, it's still highly individual. Nobody sees the same thing when they read a book. Nobody experiences it exactly the same way. It's why books evoke such strong opinions of love and hate. It's also always supposed to be completely your own. Only you have the nuances of your characters and the smell of this room or that person in your head, so, of course, even the best adaption isn't going to be exactly what you want. They aren't going to lift the world out of your head and throw it on a screen.
And that's probably my biggest problem with adaptions. Not the disappointment of them not being what you wanted, but how they shatter the book magic. Whether you watch them before or after you read the book, the book magic doesn't work anymore. I think I most starkly noticed this with Divergent. I walked into the living room while my dad was watching the movie right before I finished reading the last book, and the second I saw the actors, it was over for me. My version of the characters and my world was shattered, and I barely cared about the end of the book (though I did cry) because I felt robbed of the genuine, unique connection I had to the series. Maybe that sounds dramatic, but it's flavored my opinions on every adaption since. And then there's examples like the Hunger Games where I read the book after the movies came out, and, even though I'd never seen the movies, they were always Liam Hemsworth and Jennifer Lawerence in my mind. I'd seen the movie posters and the commercials, and I never got the chance to create my own world. I never cared much about those books, and a lot less than with Divergent, and I have to wonder if all the expectations have something to do with it. Like I've never read Harry Potter cause I don't get what the point is. It's so saturated in our culture, I already know all the big twists and turns and what it means to be a Hufflepuff or a Ravenclaw, so why would I read, or for that matter, watch, a story I already know in a world that already fully exists.
This isn't to say that movies are a bad medium or that books are superior. I'm just saying that they are two very different experiences and formats that have different strengths. And books' strengths are movie's weaknesses and vice versa. I believe that movies should be used for stories told from a strong prospective where you see it in one direction. You're experiencing it as an observer, and you need a story that derives power from the degree of separations and the use of different angles and the intensity of a performance. Movies serve a different purpose, and, when you shoehorn a book into that role, you often end up with a flattened version of the original book because you're getting one person's interpretation of a story you've already made your own, and it doesn't come with the emotional attachment you've grown with in the story.
For me, most of them range from inoffensive to "I can't even look at the book I used to love anymore", so, more often than not, my heart sinks when I hear a book I love is getting adapted. I'd rather watch an original story if I'm watching a movie or a show. I think, given time and a sincere attachment, they can be good, but it's still nerve-racking.
Thinking about positives, the only adaption I found that truly shown and stood on its own was Looking For Alaska, because I think that series hit at the right time with the right consideration of what the book is at its core. It obviously had an insane budget. Someone combed every detail from the set to the costumes to the incredible soundtrack. But, here's the thing, that book is well over ten years old. It's had a long lifetime as a book, and the only thing they were actively capitalizing on was John Green's, at this point, well established, name. It was spearheaded by two people who had been working to get it made forever. They'd taken on the story as their own and sat with it in a similar way John had done originally. They took it to a place where they'd have space not only to keep everything but add to it and make it their own. That adaption worked because they made it its own thing. You didn't have to have any love for the book to get a ton out of the show. They used a lot of the book's existing dialogue. They understood that they were doing a deeply internal story at a limited distance. It carried an awareness most lack because so many YA adaptions are considered decently cheap rom-coms for teen girls who are generally viewed as uncritical. The way Looking For Alaska was approached felt like a Euphoria. It felt designed and marketed to be sold as its own thing.
That's the framing I would like to see as we adapt going forward. If you're going to use an existing property, writers and directors need to let go of the fear of truly telling their own story within that world. More than anything, I want a piece of art where I can feel every bit of pain and emotion and joy that the creators either brought to it or felt in the process.
And that's what so many adaptions are missing.

More on This...
Looking For Alaska on Hulu

Links of Interest:

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Halsey's I Would Leave Me If I Could Poetry Review

  I Would Leave Me If I Could  by Halsey  I've started this review a couple times and scrapped all of them. I've written hundreds of reviews before, and this is the first time I have absolutely no clue how to review a book. It's not just because it's poetry. And it's not because I don't have thoughts on every single poem. I've read the book twice and scrubbed a million notes around her words and highlighted every poem on my second read through. I have so many favorites, and my heart feels like it's going to burst after finishing each poem. Halsey exceeded every expectation I had set to the high bar of her music. I almost feel like this book is too good for my review to remotely do it justice, so I don't even know where to begin.  This book is extremely vulnerable. Halsey has never held back on telling the ugly truth in her lyrics, but the poetry takes it so much farther. She has space to tell the entire story, fewer constraints than what will fit in

Swimming Lessons By Lili Reinhart Poetry Review

  Swimming Lessons  by Lili Reinhart  Overall: 5 This is the first poetry book I've ever read in its entirety outside of Shel Silverstein, so I've checked off one of my reading goals for the year with this one. I've now read a graphic novel and a book of poetry. I've been anticipating Swimming Lessons  so long that I can't believe it's actually in my hands. I've been a fan of Lili since Riverdale, and I've continued to be a fan of hers even when the show got a bit too ridiculous for me to keep watching every week. I've been excited for the chance to get to see something completely created a controlled by Lili.  I'm not sure what I expected from Swimming Lessons . I think I had almost no idea what it would be like or the topics it would cover. After the first couple poems, I was completely hooked. In the intro, Lili prefaces the collection by noting that poetry has always given her solace in knowing other people felt the same specific emotions tha

Perfect on Paper: YA Book Review

  Perfect on Paper  by Sophie Gonzales (2021 Release!) Preorder The Book on Bookshop! Before I get into the review, I'm just so excited to be writing a book review! I hadn't finished a book since the end of September :(. Hopefully that's over now. Anyway... Overview: Darcy is like Hannah Montana. Well, kinda. She's not a secret pop star, but she does have a hidden identity. She's the girl behind Locker 89, home of the best relationship advice in California. Or, at least, at her high school. People drop a letter and $10 in the locker, and Darcy collects them after school when her mom, a teacher there, stays late. This goes perfectly until Brougham catches her. While it's a minor disaster, he has a fascinating Australian accent and some traces of charm, and he ropes Darcy into giving him personal relationship coaching to win back his ex-girlfriend. But maybe he doesn't want his ex-girlfriend back after all? And maybe Darcy could get over her painful crush on h

Together, Apart YA Book Review

  Together, Apart  Anthology  Overall: 4.5 Finally writing a book review again! I read Together Apart  over the weekend, and I really enjoyed it. It's the only mainstream pandemic centric YA book out there (that I know of), which was also super interesting. I'm someone who processes what I'm going through in the moment through other people's work and recounting of experiences and through reading. With the pandemic, there hasn't been that chance. While most people are on the side of reading as escapism and not wanting books to acknowledge the pandemic, I've been craving it, and I want to write it as well (probably never will because everyone is so against it). Books and writing are how I process things. Together, Apart gave me a chance to do that. At a certain point, I think I started reading less because some days it hurt to read about teens on some other timeline living the high school/college life that feels like it's passing me by. So, I will go out on th

Books I'm Looking Forward To: November 2020 (5 YA Books and Poetry!)

Sorry I've been gone so much this month! It's hard to keep up my regular reading schedule with school. The last two weeks, I've been dealing with midterms and finals for different classes, so there's been plenty of extra work. I'm working on getting back to reading so I can share some more reviews with you very soon, but I should be back to regular posting this week.  Since it's almost a new month, I figured it's a good time to get excited about the brand new books that are coming in November and get some last minute preordering done to support these books! This month is a little bit different because I'm including a broader range of titles. I have a couple I've preordered already, some suggested to me on Twitter, a fantasy book I'm considering reading, and a book of poetry that I have wanted for months and months. I can't believe Halsey's book is finally out. In each book feature, there's a preorder button you can click to preorder t

October Wrap Up

  This month has been a journey. I've tried to write this wrap up like 5 times now, and I keep stumbling because, for one, I read almost nothing this month. From a more personal standpoint, this month was the biggest disaster of the year but had some of my favorite moments. Life is annoyingly complicated like that. I hardly remember the beginning of October it was so stressful. I finally bought Halloween decoration, which I've wanted to do for the last year or two. I stuck them around the house to get in the spirit for my favorite holiday instead of hanging them up outside like I normally do. Since I rarely leave, they're way more fun to pass on the way into the kitchen, and I'm going to miss my skeleton dragon and ghoul/skeleton man when Halloween is over.  Mostly, in October, I've felt overwhelmed. Overwhelmed by my life at home, overwhelmed by school, overwhelmed about the million responsibilities I make up for myself, and overwhelmed by feelings of failure aimed

They Wish They Were Us: YA Book Review

  They Wish They Were Us  by Jessica Goodman TW: Murder/Death of a Teen (off page generally), violence, brutal initiation tasks, attempted sexual assault (on page but brief; it gets stopped) Overview: Jill has always felt uneasy about being a Player. She worked hard and endured plenty of initiation torture to win her place among the elite group of high schoolers at Gold Coast Prep, but there's a sick feeling in her stomach as she finally takes her senior crown as one of their leaders. Maybe it was because of the brutal treatment she endured, maybe it was because her best friend Shelia died suspiciously initiation night. A fellow Player, Shelia's boyfriend Graham, got blamed for the murder before the night was over. That should be three years in the past, but a text from Rachel, a former player and Graham's sister stirs up all of Jill's questions again.  Overall: 4 Note: I heard about and read this book because Halsey and Sidney Sweeny will be staring in the adaption of

This Is All Your Fault Blog Tour Stop

  Hi, everybody! Today, I'm a part of a book tour for Turn the Pages Tours letting you know about Aminah Mae Safi's book, This Is All Your Fault . If you've always dreamed about working in a bookstore, this new book will be perfect for you. It's about a group of teen booksellers who have to band together to help save the store. Check out the full  description  down below to get to know the book and learn more about Aminah through her author bio and the links to her social media! If you want to pick up the book right now, I'll leave a link to the book on Bookshop here which helps support the blog because it's an affiliate link, which means the blog might get a small  commission  from your purchase at no extra cost to you. It's a great way to  support  the blog while shopping for books! If you'd rather not shop at Bookshop, here's the general purchase link .  Description:  Set over the course of one day, Aminah Mae Safi's This Is All Your Fault is

Into YA with Kristina Forest

I'm super excited to bring you another edition of Into YA, this time with one of my new favorite YA authors, Kristina Forest. While I'm sure you've already heard about Now That I've Found You , you can get caught up by reading my review here. Thank you to Kristina for taking the time to chat with me, and I hope you enjoy our conversation. If you want to help support the blog, please consider grabbing a copy through my Bookshop affiliate link here .    1. In Now That I Found You, all of your main characters are famous. Evie and her family are huge in the film industry, and love interest, Milo, is on the rise with his band. Did that require extra research to write about for either the music or film industries? It didn’t require much research. I’ve always been interested in old Hollywood and I’m a big fan of movies and music, and I’ve watched dozens of documentaries and/or biopics so I felt pretty prepared to write the story without having to do additional research. 2. Onc

Grown: YA Book Reviews

  Grown  by Tiffany D. Jackson TW: (from the title page of the book) sexual abuse, rape, assault, child abuse, kidnapping, and addiction to opioids  Overview: Enchanted just wants to be a singer. Living in the suburbs, she doesn't know how this will happen until she gets noticed by Korey Fields at an audition. She doesn't make the show, but she gets taken under his wing. She just wants a career, and she wants to be loved, and she wants to be told she's beautiful. Korey does all that and more. He also has money and power- more things Enchanted lacks. She wants to be an adult and take life on, but she's fallen into the hands of an abuser and master manipulator. Coming out the other side leaves Korey dead and Enchanted trying to find her footing. Overall: 5 Characters: 5 All of these characters are extremely vivid. Enchanted is such a good main character. She has confidence and is so smart. But you can see her little vulnerabilities that Korey expertly exploits. It's c