The Palm House by Gwendoline Riley: book review (booker longlist)
The Palm House by Gwendoline Riley
I thought I would love this book so much that I'd want to own a copy, so I skipped the 80 person long line at the library and bought the book. This was not the right choice.
In its summarization, it sounds like a very me book. It's about a literary magazine that gets a new editor and everyone is sent into chaos trying to cope with this change in power. It opens with an engaging conversation between two people at a bar, watching the irregular weather pattern turn the London skyline orange. This was intriguing. I wanted to read a book set at a literary magazine. I thought that's what I was getting.
Instead, Riley delivers a novel of sorts in three loosely connected parts. It reads a lot like Transcription by Ben Lerner, another book that did not live up to the hype for me this year. If I'd caught the Lerner blurb on the black in white font against the orange background, I might not have bothered to purchase the book. Simply because he doesn't seem to work in a register of storytelling that does it for me (at least in my admittedly limited experience with his work).
The first section of the book is Gatsby-esque in the sense that the section is about Putnam, an employee of the literary magazine that is leaving because of the change in editor, but it is narrated by an "I" we know absolutely nothing about. This first section I had some hope information would be revealed that would make these disjointed conversations gel. Instead, in part 2, we learn a bit about who the "I" is, not really her connection to Putnam but random details from her childhood and young adulthood. In the most interesting passage of the book, Riley tells the story of a comedian the narrator becomes obsessed with as a teenager and how, as with many situations where a fan gets to access their idol, she is groomed and taken advantage of. I feel like Riley depicted this well. Her clinical remove in relating the events felt quite real, and it was the only time it felt like there was a true multi-faceted character on the page. For most of the book, it just feels like there's a bunch of empty bread sacks having conversations that the reader does not have enough context to fully appreciate. I feel like I was really missing something here, an element that brought the book to life for people that I didn't unlock in my read.
I grew incredibly bored and increasingly mad at myself for buying the book. Another random thing that really detracted from my reading experience was that Riley has a tendency to have a character speak a sentence or two and then start a new paragraph with a single sentence where the same character is still talking, which made me frequently confuse who was talking because, typically, a new paragraph, unless part of a long monologue, indicates a new character is speaking. An added layer of confusion was not what I needed in a book that was already as thin as The Palm House felt to me.
Usually, I have a decent idea of what a novel is setting out to accomplish by the time I've finished it, even if I don't feel like it ever arrived in that place. With this book, I'm honestly not sure what whole I was meant to gather from these extraordinarily disparate parts, even if some of the sentences were pretty.
Overall: 2.5



Comments
Post a Comment